Annual Report to NC-140

 

 

2019 Brian Butler Block

 
 
Spur Development - Gala Leader

 
 
Free-Standing Geneva Rootstock Tree Losses from Wind 2019

 
 
Gala on M9 Necrosis at Graft Union

 
Free Standing Geneva Rootstock Tree Failure Due to Necrosis of Rootstock and Into Graft Union 2019

Annual Report to NC-140
Maryland Agricultural Experiment Station
November 13-14, 2019 –Geneva, NY

Chris Walsh (Leader) Carol Allen, Bryan Butler, Michael Newell, Douglas Price, Karen Rane, Macarena Farcuh (MAES attendee at the Geneva meeting)

Cooperator: Gennaro Fazio Cornell – Geneva

2019 Observations of Apple Tree and Trellis Losses in the Mid-Atlantic Region

Severe summer weather led to a number of tree and trellis losses in Mid-Atlantic apple orchards. To better understand these losses we visited orchards and took samples to identify potential biotic and abiotic agents leading to tree deaths.

Wind damage led to some top-dominant trees snapping at the graft union. More frequently this occurred at the soil line. Breakage does not appear to be virus-related. It appears that wind breaks weak-growing rootstocks at the soil line. We have seen this in some Geneva rootstocks and also in Bud9, and M9. Examination of damaged trees has shown limited rooting with necrotic areas of bark, cambium and heart wood in the rootstock shank (see attached figures). Opportunistic ambrosia beetles and Botryosphaeria rot were also found in these weakened trees.

2019 NC-140 Apple Rootstock Trial

This NC-140 replicated trial was planted in Spring 2019, one year later than originally planned. During the first growing season trees were set, trellises were built, and trees were trained to the tall spindle system as specified in the protocol. (Photos documenting the research orchard are included as an appendix to this annual report)

We have 100% tree survival in this planting. Trees grew well and reached the top wire of the trellis by the end of this first growing season. In addition to making good growth trees also began setting flower buds, and we anticipate a partial crop in August 2020.

2011 Maryland Apple Rootstock Planting

Dr. Gennaro Fazio propagated and shipped bare-root Fuji apple trees in 2010 for a trial at the Wye REC in Queenstown, Maryland. BC-2 Fuji scions were bench-grafted onto M.9 roots and a series of Geneva elite selections. Trees were containerized and grown in an outdoor pot-lot during the 2010 growing season. Four trees of each scion/rootstock combination were set in a research plot in the following spring. Individual trees were planted in four random, complete blocks and trained to a tall-spindle trellis system.

During the following years, data on tree survival was recorded and tree size and productivity data were collected. Tree survival ranged from 50 to 100 percent. Trees losses were related to two factors:

1. Bloom infection with fireblight in the 2012 fireblight epidemic.

2. Water-logged soils in a lower spot in the field.

Two of the four Fuji/M.9 record trees were lost; one in the 2012 fireblight epidemic and a second tree in 2015. Fuji trees on three of the Geneva selections were also lost that year. Trees were also lost in 2013 and 2014. Those rootstocks may have also been affected by the blight epidemic as no rootstock suckers were noted afterwards. Trees lost in 2018 were probably affected by excessive rainfall and waterlogged soils.

 

Rootstock

(Survival)

Year lost and problem observed

1.

5087 (3/4) 2015 Brittle union
2. 5257 (4/4)  
3. 4003 (3/4)  2012 Fireblight
4.

3001

Not on map
5. 6210 (3/4) 2012 Fireblight
6. 4809 (3/4) 2014 ?
7. Rootstock ? (4/4)  
8. 22-6969 (3/4) 2014 ?
9. 4011 (2/3) 2013 Fireblight
10. 3902 (3/4) 2012 Fireblight
11. 4292 (3/4) 2018 Wet feet
12. G935 (3/4) 2018 Wet feet
13. M9-337 (2/4) 2012 Fireblight and 2015 ?
14. 3010 (1/2) 2014 ?
15. 4214 (4/4)  
16. 4004 (4/4)  
17. 4814 (4/4)  

Published Written Works:

No published works in 2019.
Manuscript in preparation summarizing the 2011 BC-2 Fuji planting

Scientific and Outreach Presentations

Chris Walsh discussed apple rootstock plantings and possible solutions at the Maryland State Horticultural Society Summer Orchard Tour in Winchester, Virginia on July 10, 2019. This was also discussed at the Mid-Atlantic Orchard Twilight in Howard County on June 6, 2019. About 40 growers attended the Summer Tour and 70 attended the Twilight Meeting.

The annual orchard twilight at the Western Maryland REC in Keedysville, MD was held on August 15, 2019. The 2019 NC-140 rootstock planting was shown to growers during the evening walking tour led by Bryan Butler. Kari Peter, plant pathologist at Penn State, also discussed problems with apple rootstocks and the current epidemic of RAD (Rapid Apple Decline). About 70 fruit growers and extension educators attended this program.

Fund Leveraging

Walsh, CS, B. Butler 2017. Developing the perfect slender spindle pedestrian orchard for direct market and pick-your-own apple growers in Maryland. Maryland Specialty Block Grant Program (SCBGP). $30,494.

 

End posts and support system for 2019 tall spindle planting
Figure 1. End posts and support system for 2019 tall spindle planting. Gala record trees (background) reached the top wire of the trellis in the planting year. Cripps Pink trees in the guard row did not reach the top wire (foreground).

Spur development in October 2019 on main axis of Gala trees in the 2019 planting.
Figure 2. Spur development in October 2019 on main axis of Gala trees in the 2019 planting. We expect to harvest a light crop of apples in the second leaf.

Bark necrosis of the rootstock below the graft union on Gala/M9 trees in the 2019 NC140 planting.
Figure 3. Bark necrosis of the rootstock below the graft union on Gala/M9 trees in the 2019 NC140 planting. We are unsure if this damage was caused by a biotic or an abiotic stress.

Severe winds in 2018 and 2019 led to significant tree losses in Mid-Atlantic orchards
Figure 4. Severe winds in 2018 and 2019 led to significant tree losses in Mid-Atlantic orchards. This research block, budded on G969 rootstock was removed at the end of the season.

Tree failure due to necrosis of the rootstock and into the graft union.
Figure 5. Tree failure due to necrosis of the rootstock and into the graft union. Note the suckering from the functional side of the rootstock.